Library Renovation by amcgee
Just Started / Public / University of Michigan / Architecture, Graphic Design
Old Image on Left, Newer Technique for Image on Right. Thoughts?
AMCGEE / Projects
LIBRARY RENOVATION / Mark-ups
None at this time.
LIBRARY RENOVATION / Quick Critiques
None at this time.
4 Comments
lvroche
hmm.. I think I like the older version more. The angle of the perspective makes the space feel more impressive, and the ambiguous materiality coupled with the scale figures really draws attention to the various levels (which was part of the project, right?) Also, is the ceiling you show in the first rendering part of the existing library? Where did it go in the second one?
March 27th, 2009 8:35 pm
mhettler
i actually like the materiality of the second one because it's a little less ambiguous and allows for some really great contrasts of light and shadow. but i agree with lvroche that the first perspective is a little more impressive. it looks like the angle is the same, but you just cropped the second one -- was that on purpose? either way, i think once you get some people in there (and i would go with some really colorful images for that), it will really come together.
April 07th, 2009 6:08 pm
villalta
I agree with them above the angle is a lot better in the first iteration. I also like the lightness of the first one. The second one looks to real in a way. maybe it's just as simple as putting some photoshop filters on there and working with the contrast. To dark.
October 01st, 2009 2:16 pm
villalta
also what happened to the coffered ceiling?!
October 01st, 2009 2:40 pm
Log in to comment.